Good idea/bad idea?

[evilgrin72]

To respond to HULK's insistence that they not reveal what they know about possible roles thusly :

Why would the GGs be at a disadvantage by knowing that Pippin/Merry or Boromir/Faramir are actually in the game or not? All it does is remove possible fakes the BGs can use when we run them up. Unless your hope is that a BG will claim a role that doesn't exist, and you know this, so they can be immediately outed. Gene also insinuated that perhaps members of the Fellowship can join your board. If this is so, you should now know this after finding Gollum. That info would be useful, as we can use all the confirmed GGs we can get.

[worm]

I think just the part about knowing which roles are in the game is good. I'd leave out the rest.

[evilgrin72]

I used the first sentence only. Gene is being very evasive when I ask him things, so either he really thinks I am BG and fishing for info or his claim is BS from jumpstreet.

[worm]

May 8, 2008 14:39:00 GMT -5 evilgrin72 said:

I used the first sentence only. Gene is being very evasive when I ask him things, so either he really thinks I am BG and fishing for info or his claim is BS from jumpstreet.

Yep, pretty much.

[evilgrin72]

Well, he just answered my question, but as usual, provided no information. What's your read on him at this point, legit or BS?

[worm]

legit...

but on the off chance he's not legit I bet the real Sam comes out soon and counterclaims, so i think we're good either way

[evilgrin72]

I'm beginning to believe him too, but that first half-assed claim sure seemed like he was saying he could add us to his mason board, and he hasn't said a word about it since. I'd have thought I'd left enough hints that if this were the case, he'd view me tonight and get it done (if he's on the level, he thinks I'm a BG, though)